Problems with "sinful nature is sin" idea
The concept that "sinful nature is sin" presents several significant problems, particularly when measured against the definition of sin and the requirements for holiness found in the sources. Furthermore, this idea directly conflicts with the preparation and purification process demanded of the saints before the close of probation. Here is a breakdown of the problems associated with this concept, according to the sources: I. Problems with the Idea that Sinful Nature is Sin The core problem with equating "sinful nature" (inherited propensity or tendency to evil) with "sin" (actual transgression) is that it undermines the standard of righteousness and the possibility of victory that Christ offers. 1. Sin is Defined as Transgression of the Law The sources consistently define sin not merely as an inherited condition, but as an active or willful violation of God's revealed will: Sin is the transgression of the law . The law of God is the only perf...
